Loop compensation for TNY274
hello. Figure 1, Page 1 of the DI-173
http://www.powerint.com/sites/default/files/PDFFiles/di173.pdf
......has loop compensation components R6 and C7. -However, the TNY274 datasheet states that the TNY274 uses on/off control and that no loop compensation is needed.
If no loop compensation is needed, then why has compensation components been used in the di-173 document as stated above?
Comments
Although the EN pin of the TNY274 is sampled digitally the control loop is still an analog system and therefore feedback loop compensation is still required. If you were to look at the current through the transistor Q1 you would see than it is a DC level just below the disable threshold for the EN pin rather than a digital square wave.
Cheers
PI-Chekov
Thankyou both very much.....in truth, i would say that using such particular values for R6 and C7 and U2 is a waste of time...its just more components for assembly staff to get wrong..................In truth, for a LED supply, who cares if there is a bit of oscillation on there?....it will not be much oscillation........it will not effect the visual appearance of the LED light......i would just suggest a simple comparator circuit with the current sense resistor.......it WILL keep the LED current easily constant ENOUGH.........And it will DEFINETELY prevent the LED current from going too high........it will do this latter better than the compensated Op-Amp solution that i referred to in my previous post..............................I admit that you may get a small bit of ripple in the LED current......but it will not have any visual effect on the LED light that you see.........................So my question is one of.......what have i missed here that makes me speak so "out-of-turn".......or are you in agreement with me?
"Perfection" is the ENEMY of "perfectly_satisfactory"
I tend to agree - for a LED application where the load is constant if the oscillation causes and acceptable amount of current ripple through the LEDs then it's ok. For a voltage output supply - oscillation may result in poor transient response - something that doesn't occur with a fixed LED load. In general I would still recommend compensation components just to prevent something unexpected.
Cheers
PI-Chekov
